Whenever there’s a need to change the sets, the location or most damning of all, the opening credits, you know a show is in mid flight over Shamu in the Sea World’s Center Tank. Change the credits and you damn the show. There have been several examples. Like when they moved Bob and Emily from their then-current apartment to their new swanky 1970′s penthouse in The Bob Newhart Show and the producers changed the opening credits to match, giving the once-wry opening a newer, funkier, almost disco-ish sound
Monk lost its freshness just about the time Randy Newman came to town.
And now, most glaringly, Big Love.
For the first three seasons, BL was an intriguing if not voyeuristic examination of ordinary family life as lived by polygamists in Utah. Barely any cussing and a big focus on the recipe that bakes us as a society: working at the office, dating, high school, and dysfunctional relatives mixed together with a generous amount of graphic sex and sparingly covered with insights into a uniquely American faith.
The characters were real and textured with both likable values and unlikable shortcomings: Bill Paxton as Bill the Patriarch who tried to bring his faith into the 21st century; Jeanne Tripplehorn as Barb, the first wife who battled her family’s new priorities while trying to cling to her Mormon roots; Ginnifer Goodwin as Margene, the third wife who was fresh, sexy but naive and finally Chloe Sevigny as the stoic, mechanically inclined second wife Nikki, who compensated for her lack of intimacy by purchasing every retail object in sight.
The characters and their struggles were organic and realistically drove the plot. Their credits were imaginative, incorporating the natural beauty of Utah to represent the seeming perfection of your typical happy family that just happens to have three wives. There’s the developing fissure in the iced over lake all the characters skate upon suggesting the struggle and tension that was simmering just beneath the cool, icy surface. Everything was perfect as long as there wasn’t too much pressure.
But season four is a disaster. It’s still required viewing if for only watching how quickly and steeply a show can fall from its lofty perch. What’s the problem? There are several issues:
- The tone is off– way off. You get the feeling you’re watching a comedy half of the time, and that’s during the serious moments (like any scene involving Matt Ross as the sexually masquerading leader of the Compound or Douglas Smith as the worst Christian Rock musician ever)
- There’s too much going on at once. Bill runs for Senate so he can out the family on his own terms. Bill and the Tribe open a family friendly casino on the reservation. Margene shows affection for her “son” Benny, then marries the fiance of Bill’s one-time fourth wife so he can stay in the country. (Someone write a part for The Ropers. This is way too Three’s Company.) Barb runs the casino and her husband’s campaign while fighting off threats from a lobbyist/consultant (Sissy Spacek, who’s very good) and the smoldering affections of one of the casino partners. Then there’s a whole bunch of other stuff like arranged marriage, murder, homosexual affairs and illegal birds. Golly.
- HBO should syndicate this season on Soap Network. The drama has been cranked up to “eleven” creating a jarring, low-calorie decaffeinated melodrama that not only doesn’t satisfy, but leaves an annoying after taste. The characters no longer drive the plot. They are simply place holders, avatars (yeah, that’s right) whose only reasons for existence are to drive the plot. That’s okay when you’re making a ninety minute thriller, not so effective when you’re extending the life of an insightful drama
As a result, the producers decided to spend their extra budget on a new credit sequence that lost the subtlety and metaphor of the original and replaced it with one that hits us over the head with the theme of this season: everything is fragile and can easily fall apart. Thanks to the over ninety seconds of watching the leads fall through the black emptiness in billowy outfits, I get it.